Science for
Sustainable
Agriculture
Quote of
the week
"If we tried to feed the global population today on the average agricultural yields of the 1960s, we would need to farm over 85 percent of global land, instead of the 35 percent we use currently."
Professor Robert Henry
University of Queensland
Sign-up
Join our mailing list to receive regular email bulletins and comment from Science for Sustainable Agriculture.
comment
“A few years ago, we also studied the trade-offs between high yields and external environmental effects, measured per unit of product. Contrary to our expectations, we found the external harms of high-yielding systems quite often turned out to be much lower than those of more extensive systems, such as organic farming. In terms of nitrogen and phosphate losses, from different dairy systems, for example, the difference was a factor of two. So if you want to reduce pollution, you should probably avoid organic milk.”
Professor Andrew Balmford
University of Cambridge
Read full article HERE
must reads
A Win for Common Sense and Science
Guillermo Breton, Global Farmer Network, April 2024
A Win for Common Sense and Science – Global Farmer Network
Turning plants blue with gene editing could make robot weeding easier
New Scientist, April 2024
Turning plants blue with gene editing could make robot weeding easier | New Scientist
Rejoice! You Are Living in the Golden Age of Fruit
Noah Rothman, National Review, April 2024
Fruit & Genetic Engineering: You Are Living in the Golden Age of Fruit | National Review
The glyphosate debate: Facts, risks and benefits
Jeff Miller, AgProud, April 2024
The glyphosate debate: Facts, risks and benefits | Ag Proud
Bumblebees Don't Care about Pesticide Cocktails
University of Würzburg, April 2024
Bumblebees Don't Care about Pesticide Cocktails - (uni-wuerzburg.de)
M&S invests £1m in tackling methane from burping and farting cows
The Guardian, April 2024
M&S invests £1m in tackling methane from burping and farting cows | Marks & Spencer | The Guardian
US bets on climate friendly farming; experts doubt it is climate friendly enough
Reuters, April 2024
US bets on climate friendly farming; experts doubt it is climate friendly enough (msn.com)
EU Continues Its Unscientific, Anti-Innovation Regulation Of Genetic Engineering
Henry Miller & Rob Wager, ACSH, April 2024
Why humanity is good for the natural world
Matt Ridley, Spiked, April 2024
Why humanity is good for the natural world - spiked (spiked-online.com)
Cut pesticide use, but how?
Pieter de Wolf, WUR, April 2024
Cut pesticide use, but how? - WUR
What if global emissions went down instead of up?
Pilita Clark, Financial Times, April 2024
What if global emissions went down instead of up? (ft.com)
From novelty to necessity? The evolution of insect farming
Elaine Watson, AgFunder News, April 2024
From novelty to necessity? The evolution of insect farming (agfundernews.com)
An assessment of the linkages between GM crop biotechnology and climate change mitigation
Stuart J. Smyth et al, GM Crops and Food, April 2024
Feeding the world, whilst "sparing land"? Debating the rise of modern Brazilian agriculture
Adam Tooze, Chartbook, April 2024
China approves 81 GM seeds to boost maize & soybean as Indian biotech is blocked & crop yields languish
TCA Sharad Raghavan, The Print, April 2024
Coalition Created to Advocate for Farmers’ Access to Critical Crop Protection Tools
Modern Ag Alliance, April 2024
Can World Hunger Ever Be Eliminated? Not Using Europe Or The UN
Hank Campbell, Science 2.0, April 2024
Can World Hunger Ever Be Eliminated? Not Using Europe Or The UN | Science 2.0 (science20.com)
Solar farms are taking us back to the dark ages
Matt Ridley, The Telegraph, April 2024
Solar farms are taking us back to the dark ages (telegraph.co.uk)
Can Africa one day help feed the world’s growing population?
Financial Times, April 2024
Can Africa one day help feed the world’s growing population? (ft.com)
How misinformation is making us fear our food
Jessica Steier, The Hill, April 2024
How misinformation is making us fear our food | The Hill
Quantifying changes in the environmental impact of in-crop herbicide use in Saskatchewan, Canada
Stuart J. Smyth et al, Weed Technology, March 2024
The Farmers are Fighting this One Alone
David Zaruk, The Risk-Monger, March 2024
The Farmers are Fighting this One Alone – The Risk-Monger
Organic foods are not healthier...or pesticide free.
Dr Andrea Love, Immunologic, March 2024
Organic foods are not healthier...or pesticide free. (substack.com)
The Era Of Healthier Produce Thanks To Science Is Just Getting Started
Juergen Eckhardt, Forbes, March 2024
The Era Of Healthier Produce Thanks To Science Is Just Getting Started (forbes.com)
How technology is making flour production more sustainable and healthier
Andrew Tindall, British Baker, March 2024
How technology is shaping the future of wheat farming | British Baker (bakeryinfo.co.uk)
Biotech Matters: Innovation in Agricultural Biotechnology
L. Val Giddings, CNAS, March 2024
The EU Continues Its Unscientific, Anti-Innovation Policymaking
Rob Wager & Henry Miller, European Scientist, March 2024
The EU Continues Its Unscientific, Anti-Innovation Policymaking (europeanscientist.com)
Synergizing biotechnology and natural farming: pioneering agricultural sustainability through innovative interventions
Anila Badiyal et al, Frontiers in Plant Science, March 2024
India needs a new maize revolution
The Hindu Business Line, March 2024
India needs a new maize revolution - The Hindu BusinessLine
New research shows unintended harms of organic farming
AFP, March 2024
New research shows unintended harms of organic farming (yahoo.com)
Perspective: Can organic and conventional farming coexist peacefully?
Tim Durham, AgDaily, March 2024
Can organic and conventional farming coexist peacefully? | AGDAILY
Plant-killing genetic technology could wipe out superweeds
Michael Le Page, New Scientist, March 2024
Plant-killing genetic technology could wipe out superweeds | New Scientist
Twenty-eight years of GM Food and feed without harm: why not accept them?
Richard E. Goodman, National Library of Medicine, March 2024
Twenty-eight years of GM Food and feed without harm: why not accept them? - PubMed (nih.gov)
The EU Commission strikes again – New patent ban?
Dr Ute Kilger, European Biotechnology, March 2024
Climate and food security concerns prompting new openness to technology in agriculture
Real Agriculture, March 2024
Nutrition and food production: Our greatest challenges for the next 30 years
European Scientist, March 2024
Nutrition and food production: Our greatest challenges for the next 30 years (europeanscientist.com)
Consumer benefits from tech a key part of acceptance
Editorial, The Western Producer, March 2024
Consumer benefits from tech a key part of acceptance | The Western Producer
2023: An Activist Annus Horribilis
David Zaruk, Seed World Europe, March 2024
2023: An Activist Annus Horribilis - Seed World
Costs of inappropriately regulating all seed innovations as GMOs are too high for South Africa
Lukeshni Chetty, Daily Maverick, March 2024
'Healthy' purple tomato developed in Norwich not for sale in UK over GM restrictions
ITV News, March 2024
China develops higher yielding wheat
World Grain, February 2024
China develops higher yielding wheat | World Grain (world-grain.com)
Salmon ova heavyweights urge Norway to allow gene editing
Fish Farming Expert, February 2024
Salmon ova heavyweights urge Norway to allow gene editing (fishfarmingexpert.com)
Economic Sustainability vs. Environmental Sustainability
Stuart Smyth, SAIFood, February 2024
Economic Sustainability Vs. Environmental Sustainability - SAIFood
Why firms are racing to produce green ammonia
Chris Baraniuk, BBC News, February 2024
Why firms are racing to produce green ammonia - BBC News
Innovative Bioengineered Potatoes in Rwanda: A Beacon of Hope for Bees and Farmers Alike
BNN, 27 February 2024
Innovative Bioengineered Potatoes in Rwanda: A Beacon of Hope for … (bnnbreaking.com)
How the nod to critical pesticides will bolster India’s agricultural progress
C.D. Mayee, LiveMint February 2024
How the nod to critical pesticides will bolster India's agricultural progress | Mint (livemint.com)
Scotland’s farmers are more likely to be left at the coos tail
Brian Henderson, The Scottish Farmer, February 2024
Scotland’s farmers are more likely to be left at the coos tail | The Scottish Farmer
The Media And I: Enhancing The Soil To Improve Farming
Henry I. Miller, ACSH, February 2024
China’s embrace of GM crops will have global implications
Shaleen Khanal & Zhang Hongzhou, Think China, 22 February 2024
China’s embrace of GM crops will have global implications, Society News - ThinkChina
EU pesticide bans: what are the impacts and are they necessary?
Eve Thomas, Just Food, February 2024
EU pesticide bans: what are the impacts and are they necessary? - Just Food (just-food.com)
How climate change may increase pest and disease threats
Farmers Weekly, February 2024
How climate change may increase pest and disease threats - Farmers Weekly (fwi.co.uk)
Are farmers markets or supermarkets the low carbon food choice?
Mark Harris, Anthropocene, February 2024
Are farmers markets or supermarkets the low carbon choice? (anthropocenemagazine.org)
Agricultural chemical use and the rural-urban divide in Canada
Stuart J Smyth & Sylvain Charlebois, GM Crops & Food, February 2024
Full article: Agricultural chemical use and the rural-urban divide in Canada (tandfonline.com)
Our Obsession with Zero
David Zaruk, The Firebreak, February 2024
Our Obsession with Zero - THE FIREBREAK
The trait that could transform wheat farming
Tom Allen-Stevens, Views on Agriculture, February 2024
The trait that could transform wheat farming - Views on Agriculture
The scientific case for land sparing is compelling
Daniel Pearsall, Farmers Weekly, February 2024
Opinion: The scientific case for land sparing is compelling - Farmers Weekly (fwi.co.uk)
How science is helping farmers to find a balance between agriculture and solar farms
Magali Reinert, Nature, February 2024
How science is helping farmers to find a balance between agriculture and solar farms (nature.com)
PRRS virus-resistant nucleus herd ready for breeding upon regulatory approval
Ann Hess, National Hog Farmer, February 2024
MEPs sow seeds of change for gene-edited plant patentability: Will it bear bad fruit for the biotechnology industry?
Venner Shipley, 15 February 2024
Five reasons why the anti-biotech movement is in retreat
Mark Lynas, Alliance for Science, February 2024
Five reasons why the anti-biotech movement is in retreat - Alliance for Science
Uruguay wants to use gene drives to eradicate devastating screwworms
Abdullahi Tsanni, MIT Technology Review, February 2024
Uruguay wants to use gene drives to eradicate devastating screwworms | MIT Technology Review
Norway Approves GMO Canola Oil in Aquaculture: A Leap Towards Sustainable Fish Farming
BNN, February 2024
World first: disease resistant GM banana approved for consumption
Cosmos, February 2024
Queensland banana first GM fruit approved in Australia (cosmosmagazine.com)
Regenerative Agriculture – Buzzword? Bust? Or the Future of Agriculture?
Judson Christopherson, SAIFood, February 2024
Regenerative Agriculture - Buzzword? Bust? Or The Future Of Agriculture? - SAIFood
NGOs slam France’s plans to adopt EU method for measuring pesticides risk
Euractiv, February 2024
NGOs slam France’s plans to adopt EU method for measuring pesticides risk – Euractiv
The future of farming: Exploring the realities of regenerative agricultural practices
Potato News Today, February 2024
The EPA does not require warning labels for Roundup—yet Bayer lost $10 billion for not having them
Center for Truth in Science, February 2024
Soil Survivor: Using Nanotech for Regenerative Agriculture
Amanda Jasi, The Chemical Engineer, February 2024
Soil Survivor: Using Nanotech for Regenerative Agriculture - Features - The Chemical Engineer
Taking a more modified approach
Alan Emerson, Wairarapa Times-Age, February 2024
Taking a more modified approach - Wairarapa Times-Age
EU proposal to regulate gene-edited plants raises concerns for biotech and plant breeders alike
Potter Clarkson, February 2024
BVDV-Resistant Calf Created Through Gene Editing
Bovine Vet Online, February 2024
BVDV-Resistant Calf Created Through Gene Editing | Bovine Veterinarian (bovinevetonline.com)
The Buzz on ‘The Great Honey Bee Die-Off’
Michael Fumento, The American Spectator, February 2024
The Buzz on ‘The Great Honey Bee Die-Off’ - The American Spectator | USA News and Politics
We Can’t Do it Without Patents
Marcel Bruins, Seed World Europe, February 2024
We Can’t Do it Without Patents - Seed World Europe (european-seed.com)
A Global Farmer Perspective on the Opportunity Offered With New Plant Breeding Technology
Diana Lenzi, Global Farmer Network, February 2024
How Indian Farmers Are Using AI To Increase Crop Yield
Janakiram MSV, Forbes, February 2025
How Indian Farmers Are Using AI To Increase Crop Yield (forbes.com)
The EU risks losing out on farming’s genomic reboot
Anjana Ahuja, Financial Times, January 2024
The EU risks losing out on farming’s genomic reboot (ft.com)
Plastic pollution: Could genetically engineered bacteria be the solution?
Henry Miller & Kathleen Hefferon, Washington Examiner, January 2024
Plastic pollution: Could genetically engineered bacteria be the solution? - Washington Examiner
Will the USDA Ever Allow GMOs on Organic Farms?
Luke Carneal, Ambrook Research, January 2024
Will the USDA Ever Allow GMOs on Organic Farms? | Ambrook Research
Breakthrough Boosts Plant Yields in Dry Conditions
Mirage News, January 2024
Breakthrough Boosts Plant Yields in Dry Conditions | Mirage News
Green shoots of hope for Italy’s first gene-edited crop field trial
Nature, January 2024
Green shoots of hope for Italy’s first gene-edited crop field trial (nature.com)
Plant scientists turn attention to African staples
Financial Times, January 2024
https://www.ft.com/content/5ce06c10-6fb3-440e-971e-5edfc6efe5ff
CRISPR-edited crops break new ground in Africa
Nature, January 2024
https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-024-00176-8
TELA Maize paves way for Nigeria’s self-sufficiency in maize production
The Nation, January 2024
‘Perceptions and emotions’: How consumers in the U.S. and Switzerland view New Genomic Techniques in agriculture
Potato News Today, January 2024
Agriculture in a changing climate: Africa needs biotechnology
Matthias Berninger, Table Media, January 2024
Agriculture in a changing climate: Africa needs biotechnology • Table.Media
Only scientifically-proven pest controls will reduce food losses
Business Daily Africa, January 2024
Unlocking the power of gene editing
Dr Helen Ferrier, NFU Online, January 2024
Unlocking the power of gene editing – NFUonline
Cypriot scientist revolutionizes agriculture with soil-free crop growth
KNEWS, January 2024
Cypriot scientist revolutionizes agriculture with soil-free crop growth, KNEWS (kathimerini.com.cy)
The Case for Doubling Down on Agricultural R&D
Dan Blaustein-Rejto, The Breakthrough Institute, January 2024
The Case for Doubling Down on… | The Breakthrough Institute
Nigeria approves commercial release of GM maize varieties
Alex Abutu, Alliance for Science, January 2024
Nigeria approves commercial release of GM maize varieties - Alliance for Science
A good journal breaks bad: AAP spreads misinformation about glyphosate
Nicole Keller, Science-Based Medicine, January 2024
GMOs have generated $30 billion extra for Brazilians in the last 25 years
AgroPages, January 2024
Germany’s farmers are fighting back against green tyranny
Sabine Beppler-Spahl, Spiked, January 2024
Germany’s farmers are fighting back against green tyranny - spiked (spiked-online.com)
Risk-appropriate regulations for gene-editing technologies
Graham Brookes & Stuart Smyth, GM Crops & Food, January 2024
Full article: Risk-appropriate regulations for gene-editing technologies (tandfonline.com)
Genome-edited rice resistant to virus wreaking havok in Africa
Imma Perfetto, Cosmos, January 2024
Genome-edited rice variety resistant to destructive virus (cosmosmagazine.com)
New Report Urging Parents to Buy Organic Could Hurt Americans’ Health: Experts
The Messenger, January 2024
New Report Urging Parents to Buy Organic Could Hurt Americans' Health: Experts - The Messenger
Scientists’ ‘super banana’ could save thousands of lives, reduce blindness – but it still has major opposition to overcome
The Cool Down, January 2024
On solid ground: AgTech is driving sustainable farming and is expected to harvest US$18 billion in 2024
Deloitte Insights, January 2024
Agriculture technology | Deloitte Insights
Understanding China’s Food Priorities for 2024
Genevieve Donnellon-May, The Diplomat, January 2024
Understanding China’s Food Priorities for 2024 – The Diplomat
GM crops set a new global acreage record in 2023
ChileBio News, January 2024
GM crops set a new global acreage record in 2023 - ChileBIO
Rwanda Supports Technology as a Tool for Food Security
Pacifique Nshimiyimana, Global Farmer Network, January 2024
Rwanda Supports Technology as a Tool for Food Security – Global Farmer Network
Eliminating Hidden Hunger: How biofortification can improve nutrition at home and abroad
John Innes Centre, January 2024
Are GMOs Safe? The Benefits of Science-Enhanced Foods
Jamie Ducharme, Time, January 2024
Are GMOs Safe? The Benefits of Science-Enhanced Foods | TIME
CRISPR launch hopes to future-proof agrifood production
Food Navigator, January 2024
CRISPR to be used to genetically modify crops (foodnavigator.com)
Discovery raises hopes of more temperature tolerant wheat
Phys.org, January 2024
Discovery raises hopes of more temperature tolerant wheat (phys.org)
Breeding Long Term Commitment: Vegetable Companies
Eloy Corona, Seed World, January 2024
Breeding Long Term Commitment: Vegetable Companies - Seed World US
‘Modern genetic techniques offer many prospects for agroecology’: Q&A with Urs Niggli
RePlanet, December 2024
‘Modern genetic techniques offer many prospects for agroecology’: Q&A with Urs Niggli (weplanet.org)
Why Food Security is a Top Priority for China
The Diplomat, December 2023
Why Food Security is a Top Priority for China – The Diplomat
Drought-tolerant transgenic wheat HB4®: a hope for the future
Pushpendra K. Gupta, Trends in Biotechnology, December 2023
Drought-tolerant transgenic wheat HB4®: a hope for the future - ScienceDirect
Science Wins Over Politics with Decision to Extend Glyphosate Use in Europe
Frank Lessiter, No-Till Farmer, December 2023
Science Wins Over Politics with Decision to Extend Glyphosate Use in Europe (no-tillfarmer.com)
EU Commission is jeopardising future of organic farming
Opinion, EU Observer, December 2023
EU Commission is jeopardising future of organic farming (euobserver.com)
Polls reveal new pragmatism around ag biotech
American Feed Industry Association, December 2023
Polls Reveal New Pragmatism Around Ag Biotech - AFIA
Agricultural Game-Changer on the Horizon for Canola
Seed World, December 2023
Agricultural Game-Changer on the Horizon for Canola - Seed World US
Rethinking Sustainable Beef
The Breakthrough Institute, December 2023
Rethinking Sustainable Beef | The Breakthrough Institute
GMOs a solution, not a problem, says British Nobel laureate
The Nation, December 2023
GMOs a solution, not a problem, says British Nobel laureate (nationthailand.com)
How can we navigate the global food crisis with emerging technology?
Silicon Republic, December 2023
How can we navigate the global food crisis with emerging technology? (siliconrepublic.com)
How New Zealand is reducing methane emissions from farming
BBC Future, December 2023
How New Zealand is reducing methane emissions from farming - BBC Future
China corn breeders ready for doubling of GMO planting in 2024 -sources
Channel News Asia, December 2023
China corn breeders ready for doubling of GMO planting in 2024 -sources - CNA (channelnewsasia.com)
How some pesticide policies can harm food security
Amrith Gunasekara, AgAlert, December 2023
Waiting for Godot: Europe’s Quest to OK Gene Editing
Alan Schulman, CEPA, December 2023
Waiting for Godot: Europe’s Quest to OK Gene Editing - CEPA
How to Improve Livestock Health, and Cut Greenhouse Gas Emissions
The Breakthrough Institute, December 2023
How to Improve Livestock Health, and Cut… | The Breakthrough Institute
Gene editing faces opposition from Europe's green lobby
Richard Wright, The Scottish Farmer, December 2023
Gene editing faces opposition from Europe's green lobby | The Scottish Farmer
Recognising the Importance of Glyphosate as a Tool Supporting Soil Health in the EU
Knud Bay-Smidt, Global Farmer Network, December 2023
An ESG Opportunity?
David Zaruk, Seed World, December 2023
An ESG Opportunity? - Seed World Europe (european-seed.com)
Climate change means we need to get over fears about gene-editing plants
Bill Anderson, Fast Company, December 2023
Climate change means we need to get over fears about gene-editing plan (fastcompany.com)
GMOs a world food solution, not a problem
Farmers Weekly (NZ), 5 December 2023
GMOs a world food solution, not a problem (farmersweekly.co.nz)
Growing more with less
Robert Horn, International Monetary Fund, December 2023
Growing More with Less by Robert Horn (imf.org)
COP28: 7 food and agriculture innovations needed to protect the climate and feed a rapidly growing world
Paul Winters, The Conversation, December 2023
Vertically farmed greens taste as good as organic ones
Science Daily, December 2023
Vertically farmed greens taste as good as organic ones | ScienceDaily
Sustainability in Canada and Europe: An Assessment after 25 Years of GM Crop Production
Stuart J. Smith, American Chemical Society, December 2023
Are healthy foods automatically sustainable, too?
Science Daily, December 2023
Are healthy foods automatically sustainable, too? | ScienceDaily
Commentary: How ‘startling’ findings outpace thorough science in policymaking
Richard Williams & Nathan Schachtman, Jacksonville Journal Courier, December 2023
‘Startling’ outpaces science — Richard Williams, Nathan Schachtman (myjournalcourier.com)
How the Green New Deal Met Its Demise In Europe
Bill Wirtz, Real Clear Markets, November 2023
How the Green New Deal Met Its Demise In Europe | RealClearMarkets
Europe tried it green and failed
Bill Wirtz, Washington Examiner, November 2023
Europe tried it green and failed | Washington Examiner
Will higher food prices shift demand for niche market products?
Stuart Smyth, SAI Food, November 2023
Will Higher Food Prices Shift Consumer Demands For Niche Market Products? - SAIFood
Big Steps Towards Plant Breeding’s Holy Grail: Apomixis
Seed World, November 2023
Big Steps Towards Plant Breeding’s Holy Grail: Apomixis - Seed World US
Time to invest in the next agricultural revolution
Dr Matthew Partridge, Newsweek, November 2023
The next agricultural revolution is here. Time to invest. | MoneyWeek
Mexican GMO Trade Dispute Relying On Faulty Claims, Retracted Research
Rob Wager, Issues & Insights, November 2023
Science for Sustainable Agriculture news
Fresh approach needed to secure UK organic seed supply
Dr Anthony Hopkins
Twenty years since a Government-funded database was established to help organic farmers source supplies of organically produced seed, and despite a long-term decline in the UK organic area, emergency derogations allowing organic growers to use non-organic seed are at a record high. This raises concerns over the need to maintain consumer confidence in the integrity of organic production, and to prevent unfair competition with conventional growers. In addition, the prospect of widespread uptake of new precision breeding techniques, which the organic industry prohibits, suggests alternative policy approaches are needed to ensure a reliable supply of certified organic seed in the future, argues BSPB head of policy Dr Anthony Hopkins.
Food labelling schemes are not helping consumers make informed sustainability choices, nor rewarding the most sustainable farmers
Dr Harriet Bartlett
In a study published recently in the journal Nature Food, a team of researchers from the Universities of Oxford, Cambridge and São Paulo conclude that the way we classify farm types and label pork isn’t helping consumers to make informed decisions when it comes to buying more sustainable meat. Instead of singling out particular farm types or practices, the research highlights a need to focus on meaningful, measurable outcomes, and reward individual farms based on these. Lead author Dr Harriet Bartlett discusses the findings.
What is (risk) appropriate regulation of gene editing technology?
Graham Brookes & Stuart Smyth
Despite the much-hyped expectation that Europe was on course to follow other parts of the world in removing GMO-style regulatory requirements from gene edited (GE) crops, with EU elections looming and no agreement in sight the bloc now risks slipping back towards precautionary inertia. Summarising their recent peer-reviewed paper exploring risk-appropriate regulation for gene editing, agricultural economists Graham Brookes and Stuart Smyth warn that we must learn the lessons from past experience of divergent international regulation of agricultural innovations. The impact of over-precautionary EU regulation of gene editing will not only disadvantage European agriculture, but will also compromise global efforts to address urgent climate, biodiversity and food security challenges, they argue.
The importance of translating plant science into practice
Professor Mario Caccamo
The lack of long-term strategic funding for research organisations that are focused on translational research, as recently reported in the media, raises serious concerns about the future of applied crop science in the UK. Efforts to translate fundamental scientific discoveries into practical farming innovations which can boost productivity while addressing climate and biodiversity challenges are too slow and fragmented when compared to other countries. Bridging this ‘valley of death’ may require a major re-organisation of our R&D landscape, suggests NIAB chief executive Professor Mario Caccamo.
ELMS: It’s time for Defra to go back to the drawing board, and listen to the science
Matt Ridley
In the first of a series of essays examining the impact of farming innovations on food production and the environment, science writer, author and farmer Matt Ridley argues that the UK Government is squandering opportunities to accelerate the adoption of yield-boosting advances on Britain’s farms which could increase food production while freeing up land for nature. In pursuing a land-sharing approach to farm policy, Defra Ministers are failing to heed their own scientific advice, let alone the accumulating body of scientific evidence which supports a land-sparing approach as the most effective policy option to produce enough food while leaving room for nature, biodiversity and climate action.
ELMS: Defra not heeding the multiple warning signs from their own science on land-sharing vs land-sparing. Is this a leap in the dark for Britain’s farmers?
A pro-innovation think tank is calling on MPs to investigate the impact of the Government’s environmental land management schemes (ELMS) on domestic food security after a Defra-funded scientific review identified multiple risks to both food production and the environment from its land-sharing policies.
Sustainable Yield Growth - a gamechanger for the SDGs?
Dr Derrick Wilkinson
A 70% increase in global demand for food by 2050, set against urgent biodiversity and climate pressures, requires an unprecedented transformation of our food system. This challenge can in part be mitigated by reducing food losses and waste, and through dietary change. On their own, however, these measures will not be enough. Promoting sustainable yield growth provides the most powerful solution to meeting the growing food needs of billions of hungry people, while protecting biodiversity and improving the health of the ecosystems on which we all rely. If real progress is to be made toward the Sustainable Development Goals and Paris climate agreements, the technical and technological innovations at the heart of sustainable yield growth must be given the highest priority, argues retired UK economist Dr Derrick Wilkinson.
False dawn for gene edited crops in the EU?
Steven E Cerier
With Europe’s agriculture sector in turmoil, as farmers stage mass protests against unworkable environmental restrictions, new breeding technologies such as gene editing could go a long way in helping the EU achieve its sustainability goals. Considering the bloc’s stringent, historical opposition to GMOs in agriculture, the European Parliament’s recent decision to adopt looser rules for the cultivation of NBTs is a significant step forward. But the regulatory regime being proposed is not likely to set the stage for a full-scale food revolution in the EU. Without a commitment to complete deregulation, Europe will remain a genetic engineering backwater for decades to come, argues retired international economist Steven Cerier.
Why the Nuffield Council on Bioethics must revisit its report on genome editing in farmed animals
Professor the Lord Trees & Lord Curry of Kirkharle
Leading veterinarian Lord Trees and veteran farming champion Lord Curry of Kirkharle explain why they have called on the Nuffield Council on Bioethics to revise and update its 2021 report on the ethics of genome editing in farmed animals. They challenge the report’s characterisation of our food production system as ‘morally indefensible and unsustainable’, citing evidence of significant and ongoing improvements in livestock breeding and welfare improvements, driven by science. They also warn of the report’s disproportionately negative impact on the political and public debate, urging Nuffield to take greater account of the ethical implications of not embracing a technology with the potential to deliver solutions to previously intractable disease problems, such as bird flu in poultry, PRRS in pigs and BVD in cattle.
Focus on genetics and IP needed to boost Britain's horticulture sector
Peter Button
A recent one-off House of Lords inquiry into the challenges facing the horticulture industry, and the ensuing report entitled ‘Sowing the Seeds: A blooming English horticultural sector’, was a missed opportunity to put the essential genetic research, plant breeding and seed sectors which support the industry on a more secure footing, writes former UPOV Vice Secretary-General Peter Button.
Crop biotechnology opponents are losing their war against genetic engineering, but the battle for science is not yet won
Steven E. Cerier
After years of reaping the tainted rewards of disinformation, the ground is shifting against anti-biotech activists. The world’s eight most populous countries now either grow GM crops and or have approved the deregulation of gene-edited crops. That’s more than 50 percent of the global population. But for a number of countries, GMOs still remain in regulatory limbo as a residue of the Frankenfood branding by anti-biotech campaigners. In an ideal, science-driven world, with overwhelming evidence that both transgenic and gene-edited crops pose no identifiable unique health or environmental threats, the two complementary breeding techniques would face minimal regulatory hurdles. We will eventually look back upon this period of hyped worries and predictions of impending environmental catastrophe and be mystified at what all the fuss was about, writes Steven Cerier.
Harnessing the power of farm-level data
George Freeman MP
Former UK science minister George Freeman MP explains his longstanding passion, first inspired by the US Field to Market programme, for using farm-level data to drive improvements in sustainable, efficient food production, and to inform consumers about the environmental impact of their food choices. He reflects on his disappointment that the pivotal role envisaged for agrimetrics in the UK Agri-Tech Strategy has not yet transpired in practice, but highlights two recent developments which give cause for optimism that Britain may get back on track to mirror the US in harnessing the enormous potential of agricultural data and sustainability metrics.
Europe’s farmers are fighting for the ability to continue to farm
David Zaruk
While there is no single issue behind the angry farmer protests taking place across Europe, at its heart is a frustration felt among farmers that society, governments and special interests have denigrated them and their profession. Activists blame them for climate change, environmental pollution and unsustainability, when farmers see themselves as the stewards of the land. Green restrictions like the EU Farm2Fork strategy will make farming unprofitable and perhaps no longer even possible, designed by cosmopolitan zealots with no idea what is required to bring a harvest in. Farmers are fighting for the ability to continue to farm. Among other actions to stop alienating farmers, Government regulators need to speak up for the science and data when activist groups spread lies about the safety of conventional agriculture tools, rather than quietly letting the fearmongers undermine public trust in our farmers, writes EU risk and science communications specialist David Zaruk.
Is hi-tech, intensive livestock production more sustainable, more biosecure?
The Earl of Caithness
Faced with a ‘potential explosion’ of livestock disease in Britain, the Earl of Caithness highlights the enormous potential to prevent the spread of infectious diseases in farmed animals through genetic advances in which UK research is world-leading. He urges UK Ministers to speed up plans to allow the commercial use of precision breeding techniques in livestock so that these advances can be deployed as soon as possible to prevent animal suffering and to improve biosecurity. Noting that infectious diseases do not differentiate between animals reared intensively or extensively, he also refutes claims from environmental NGOs and animal welfare campaigners that more intensive forms of livestock production increase the risk of zoonotic diseases. In fact, the scientific evidence points in the opposite direction – intensive livestock farming may actually be more sustainable, and more biosecure.
Gene editing: Is it time for full disclosure of all plant breeding methods?
Nigel Moore
Plant breeder Nigel Moore notes that the public debate around gene editing has highlighted a worrying lack of awareness among consumers that none of our familiar food crops are ‘in their natural form’, and that all have been adapted and improved for society’s benefit by science-based plant breeding. Frustrated that the enormous contribution of genetic innovation in improving the quality, availability and affordability of our food supply is routinely overlooked or airbrushed out by the time products reach the supermarket shelves, he emphasises the breeding industry’s commitment to transparency, and asks if it is time for full disclosure of all plant breeding methods? Only by contextualising the way we currently improve our food crops, and by improving consumers’ access to information, can we hope to avoid a situation in which precision breeding is singled out as ‘different’ in an apparent vacuum of knowledge about other conventional breeding methods, he argues.
Throttle back on production to spite the supermarkets? Has UK farming finally lost the plot?
Paul Temple
Reflecting on discussions at this year’s Oxford Farming Conference, and with some SFI payment options reportedly offering a better return to landowners than farmers producing food, the idea that we should throttle back on production to tackle perceived imbalances in the value chain might turn out to be a catastrophic own-goal for our industry. A more secure and sustainable future for Britain’s farmers does not lie in dialling back production, battling against our customers, or relying on future taxpayer handouts for producing food less efficiently. We urgently need farm policies which benchmark, measure and reward improvements in sustainable, efficient food production, which respond to the COP28 agenda by setting more ambitious targets for domestic output and clear goals for reducing the environmental footprint of our food system, and which encourage the use of new agricultural technology and innovation to do so, argues mixed farmer Paul Temple.
Radical rethink needed into how we regulate and incentivise the delivery of agricultural innovation in the UK
Professor Tina Barsby OBE
Expressed per head of population, or in relation to GDP, the United Kingdom leads the world in terms of high-citation academic publications in agriculture, according to a recent study. High-citation papers are defined as those most likely to support innovation and deliver impact. So why does UK leadership in academic science not translate into leadership in agricultural productivity growth, in which the UK continues to lag behind most other developed agricultural economies? And why has it not positioned the UK as a major destination for private sector investment in agricultural innovation – compared, for example, to Britain’s healthcare or medical life science sectors? Plant scientist Professor Tina Barsby offers some thoughts.
Land use: OF&G claims for organic farming benefits don’t stack up
Daniel Pearsall & Dr Julian Little
Questioning claims in a recent policy paper that trebling the area of organic farmland in England will deliver benefits for the climate and biodiversity, Daniel Pearsall and Dr Julian Little point to the increasing weight of scientific evidence that optimising food production on as small a land area as possible is the most sustainable way to feed a growing population while leaving space for nature and carbon sequestration. Any increase in organic farming will inevitably reduce yields, requiring more land elsewhere to make up for the loss in production. Peer-reviewed research indicates that this would be at a cost to biodiversity and greenhouse gas emissions much greater than the on-farm benefit of organic practice. Consistent, science-based metrics of agricultural sustainability are urgently needed, taking account of a broad range of resource use and environmental indicators, related to the quantity for food produced. Only then will we truly understand the comparative sustainability impact of our food choices. For some it may make for uncomfortable reading, they argue.
IP in agriculture benefits everyone
Peter Button
Case studies from around the world show that introducing effective systems of IP protection in agriculture supports investment, innovation and economic growth in both developed and developing countries. It also promotes greater choice and diversity of crop varieties, and incentivises efforts to protect and conserve natural biodiversity. Far from demonising the role of intellectual property in farming, we should be celebrating and championing its contribution to a more productive, resilient and sustainable global food system, argues Peter Button, former UPOV Vice-Secretary General.
Precision breeding: Food Standards Agency’s plans must not put England behind the EU
Karen Holt & Daniel Pearsall
The UK Food Standards Agency (FSA) deserves credit for the science-based progression in its thinking around the regulation of food and feed produced using precision breeding techniques such as gene editing. A recent public consultation issued by the FSA also gives cause for optimism that the Agency is thinking strategically about reform of restrictive GMO rules inherited from the EU. But with Europe fast catching up with England’s plans to deregulate gene editing techniques, could it be a case of two steps forward, one step back, ask Karen Holt and Daniel Pearsall.
Can agriculture save the planet? Insights from COP28 and beyond
Jack Bobo
The discussions at COP28 highlight the critical role of agricultural innovations in achieving food security and climate goals sustainably. The acceptance and adoption of these innovations by society are paramount. If the public does not support the introduction of such technologies, even the most groundbreaking scientific solutions will remain underutilised. Science tells us what we can do, but, ultimately, it is the public that tells us what we should do. Therefore, engaging consumers in discussions about food production is essential, writes Jack Bobo, Director of the University of Nottingham Food Systems Institute.
Defra must publish a full impact assessment of farm policies on domestic food production
Julian Sturdy MP
Highlighting concerns that a UK policy emphasis on lower-yield farming practices and land use change will inevitably take its toll on domestic food production, Julian Sturdy MP calls on Defra to publish a full impact assessment of its Environmental Land Management (ELM) and Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI) policies on farm-level yields, national agricultural productivity growth, and domestic food self-sufficiency. It is not too late to adopt a data-led approach to measure and monitor the impact of our farm policies, he argues. The Agriculture Act includes specific provisions to equip farmers with the technology to generate, collect and share data, and to support productivity improvements. Together, these policy tools could and should be used not only to track the impact of government policies, but also to inform and drive sustainable gains in agricultural productivity, and to benchmark and reward farmers for genuine progress in reducing their environmental footprint per unit of food produced. It is vital that we adopt a clear-sighted, evidence-based approach to the development and implementation of future farm policies. Otherwise, we may risk sleepwalking into a food crisis, he warns.
Which farming system better preserves insect populations: organic or conventional?
Jon Entine
Science journalist Jon Entine challenges the simplistic narrative that modern intensive agriculture is steering us toward catastrophic declines in global insect populations, highlighting to a 2020 meta-study of 166 long-term surveys which points to a levelling off of insect declines in recent decades, and an increase in some species. Global population growth and rising affluence over coming decades will require a sharp increase in necessary food calories, which can only occur by expanding farmable acreage - or by increasing yields on existing farmland. Using technology to boost yields on currently farmed acres - growing more food on less land—is the most important action we can take to protect habitat and biodiversity, he suggests, warning that a turn away from efficient, intensive agriculture to accommodate the ideological fashion of our times could be a disaster for the fragile insect population.
Regenerative agriculture - hype or hope?
Professor Mario Caccamo
As interest in regenerative agriculture reaches fever pitch across the value chain, NIAB is preparing the ground for a major research effort to deliver the science needed for a commercial scale-up of regen-ag, combining research leadership in soil science, variety testing, rotational agronomy, precision agronomy, cover cropping, data science and water use efficiency. A progressive, science-based approach, embracing innovation and harnessing the power of large-scale data, offers the potential for high-yielding, profitable crop production to go hand in hand with reducing agriculture’s environmental and climate impacts, writes Professor Mario Caccamo.
Pro-science think-tank calls for UK Agri-Tech Strategy re-set
Following the recent announcement that three of the four Agri-Tech Centres established under the 2013 UK Agri-Tech Strategy could be merged into a single Catapult, and amid reports that the fourth centre, Agrimetrics, faces an uncertain future without continued Government support, pro-science think-tank Science for Sustainable Agriculture (SSA) is calling for an evidence-led re-set of the Strategy, with a renewed focus on genetic innovation and data.
Britain's organic farmers must not be locked out of the gene editing revolution
David Hill
Momentum is building to permit gene edited crops in organic agriculture within the European Union. Meanwhile, Britain’s organic farmers risk being left behind by the campaigning stance of UK organic sector bodies, whose dogmatic rejection of these more precise breeding technologies may not reflect the views of members on the ground, warns Norfolk arable farmer and registered organic processor, David Hill.
Time for a fresh look at the UK rulebook on using the GM method for crop improvement
Professor Jonathan Jones FRS
After almost 30 years’ safe and effective use of GM crops around the world, the technology has delivered major benefits for agriculture and the environment in terms of increased yields, lower pesticide use and reduced greenhouse gas emissions. But national bans and overly-restrictive rules on GM crop cultivation have limited the global gains to just one-third of the technology’s potential. At a time of mounting concern over the food, energy and climate pressures facing the planet, The Royal Society is calling for a more proportionate and evidence-led approach to regulating GM crops in the UK, explains plant scientist Professor Jonathan Jones.
NEWS: Benefits for food security, animal welfare and the environment: New study shows balanced breeding programmes in pigs can increase litter size while also increasing birth weights and improving piglet survival rates
A new peer-reviewed study has underlined the contribution of balanced farm animal breeding programmes in delivering combined benefits in terms of food production, animal welfare and environmental impact.
Published in the journal Frontiers in Animal Science, the study examines long-term trends in commercial pig breeding since the early 2000s, focusing on data relating to litter size, piglet birth weight and piglet survival rates according to different genetic types (breeding lines).
Improvements have been most marked over the past decade, with the data showing that from 2012 until 2022, average litter size increased by 3.5 pigs, birth weight increased by 30g per pig, while piglet survival rates improved by 8%.
Label organic products, not gene edited, on food safety grounds
Daniel Pearsall & Matt Ridley
The UK Food Standards Agency (FSA) has followed the science in recommending a streamlined approach to regulating gene edited food and feed products, mirroring the rules already adopted in countries such as Canada, Argentina and Japan, and in line with the approach proposed for the EU. Howls of protest from the organic lobby demanding mandatory labelling of gene edited products must be met with the same level-headed, evidence-based response. Rather than statutory labelling of gene edited products, for which there is no scientific basis in food safety terms, the FSA might more reasonably turn its attention to requiring statutory labelling of organic products – in the same way as raw milk products – to alert consumers to the potential additional risks in terms of food safety and hygiene, write Daniel Pearsall and Matt Ridley.